Regulator's Three-Year Concerns Lead to This Trading Firm's Bankruptcy Proceedings

Thursday, 13/06/2024 | 08:29 GMT by Damian Chmiel
  • FINMA has initiated bankruptcy proceedings against FlowBank, a Swiss online broker.
  • The bank failed to maintain minimum capital requirements and potential over-indebtedness
FINMA
Bloomberg

The Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA) announced on Thursday that it has opened bankruptcy proceedings against FlowBank SA, a Geneva-based online brokerage and trading bank. The decision comes as the bank failed to maintain the minimum capital required for its business operations and faces concerns of potential over-indebtedness.

Swiss Regulator Initiates Bankruptcy Proceedings Against FlowBank SA

FlowBank SA has been under FINMA's scrutiny since October 2021, when the regulator identified serious breaches of supervisory law, particularly concerning capital requirements, organizational adequacy, and risk management. Despite the imposition of wide-ranging measures and the appointment of an independent auditor in October 2022, the bank continued to violate capital ratio requirements and maintain deficiencies in various areas of its operations.

According to FINMA, the primary objective of the bankruptcy proceedings is to protect depositors. Current calculations suggest that privileged deposits, up to CHF 100,000 per client, can be repaid in full using the bank's available funds. The regulator has appointed the law firm Walder Wyss AG as the liquidator to oversee the bankruptcy process.

In June 2023, FINMA took further enforcement action against FlowBank SA, appointing a monitor to oversee the bank's activities and investigate its compliance failures. The monitor's report revealed repeated breaches of capital requirements, inaccurate and incomplete bookkeeping and financial reporting, and failure to fulfill disclosure and reporting obligations to the regulator.

“In addition, the investigation found that the bank entered into numerous higher-risk business relationships and processed large transactions without properly investigating the background of these business relationships and transactions,” FINMA stated in the press release.

FINMA views this as a serious breach of the bank's money laundering due diligence obligations and a violation of the regulator's prohibition on the bank from engaging in additional higher-risk business activities.

License Withdrawal and Appeal

In light of the bank's persistent malpractice and inability to rectify its non-compliance with licensing conditions, FINMA made the decision to revoke FlowBank SA's banking license on March 8, 2024. The regulator also questioned the bank's assurance of proper business conduct. Although the bank has appealed the ruling to the Federal Administrative Court, FINMA has implemented various preventivedecided measures that will remain in place throughout the appeal process to safeguard against the unauthorized withdrawal of assets by the bank.

Upon reviewing FlowBank SA's 2023 financial statements, which were recently approved by the bank's board of directors, FINMA concluded that the bank's financial health could have been more precarious than had been initially disclosed. The regulator found that the bank had significantly violated minimum capital requirements at the end of 2023 and again in April 2024. Moreover, there were substantial grounds to believe that the bank was over-indebted as of April 2024.

With a total asset base of roughly CHF 680 million, FlowBank SA maintains over 22,000 client accounts and has a global workforce of approximately 140 employees, with subsidiary operations in London and the Bahamas. As the liquidation process unfolds, the appointed liquidator will prioritize reimbursing privileged deposits to affected clients. Additionally, client custody accounts will be separated from the bank's estate and returned to their rightful owners in due course.

Earlier this year, FINMA announced the appointment of former ECB chief Stefan Walter as CEO, effective April 1, 2024. Last year, FINMA's previous CEO, Urban Angehrn, resigned from his position, citing health reasons.

The Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA) announced on Thursday that it has opened bankruptcy proceedings against FlowBank SA, a Geneva-based online brokerage and trading bank. The decision comes as the bank failed to maintain the minimum capital required for its business operations and faces concerns of potential over-indebtedness.

Swiss Regulator Initiates Bankruptcy Proceedings Against FlowBank SA

FlowBank SA has been under FINMA's scrutiny since October 2021, when the regulator identified serious breaches of supervisory law, particularly concerning capital requirements, organizational adequacy, and risk management. Despite the imposition of wide-ranging measures and the appointment of an independent auditor in October 2022, the bank continued to violate capital ratio requirements and maintain deficiencies in various areas of its operations.

According to FINMA, the primary objective of the bankruptcy proceedings is to protect depositors. Current calculations suggest that privileged deposits, up to CHF 100,000 per client, can be repaid in full using the bank's available funds. The regulator has appointed the law firm Walder Wyss AG as the liquidator to oversee the bankruptcy process.

In June 2023, FINMA took further enforcement action against FlowBank SA, appointing a monitor to oversee the bank's activities and investigate its compliance failures. The monitor's report revealed repeated breaches of capital requirements, inaccurate and incomplete bookkeeping and financial reporting, and failure to fulfill disclosure and reporting obligations to the regulator.

“In addition, the investigation found that the bank entered into numerous higher-risk business relationships and processed large transactions without properly investigating the background of these business relationships and transactions,” FINMA stated in the press release.

FINMA views this as a serious breach of the bank's money laundering due diligence obligations and a violation of the regulator's prohibition on the bank from engaging in additional higher-risk business activities.

License Withdrawal and Appeal

In light of the bank's persistent malpractice and inability to rectify its non-compliance with licensing conditions, FINMA made the decision to revoke FlowBank SA's banking license on March 8, 2024. The regulator also questioned the bank's assurance of proper business conduct. Although the bank has appealed the ruling to the Federal Administrative Court, FINMA has implemented various preventivedecided measures that will remain in place throughout the appeal process to safeguard against the unauthorized withdrawal of assets by the bank.

Upon reviewing FlowBank SA's 2023 financial statements, which were recently approved by the bank's board of directors, FINMA concluded that the bank's financial health could have been more precarious than had been initially disclosed. The regulator found that the bank had significantly violated minimum capital requirements at the end of 2023 and again in April 2024. Moreover, there were substantial grounds to believe that the bank was over-indebted as of April 2024.

With a total asset base of roughly CHF 680 million, FlowBank SA maintains over 22,000 client accounts and has a global workforce of approximately 140 employees, with subsidiary operations in London and the Bahamas. As the liquidation process unfolds, the appointed liquidator will prioritize reimbursing privileged deposits to affected clients. Additionally, client custody accounts will be separated from the bank's estate and returned to their rightful owners in due course.

Earlier this year, FINMA announced the appointment of former ECB chief Stefan Walter as CEO, effective April 1, 2024. Last year, FINMA's previous CEO, Urban Angehrn, resigned from his position, citing health reasons.

About the Author: Damian Chmiel
Damian Chmiel
  • 1978 Articles
  • 47 Followers
About the Author: Damian Chmiel
Damian's adventure with financial markets began at the Cracow University of Economics, where he obtained his MA in finance and accounting. Starting from the retail trader perspective, he collaborated with brokerage houses and financial portals in Poland as an independent editor and content manager. His adventure with Finance Magnates began in 2016, where he is working as a business intelligence analyst.
  • 1978 Articles
  • 47 Followers

More from the Author

Retail FX

!"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|} !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}