Market making, STP and ECN - what they are, pros and cons

Monday, 17/08/2009 | 11:29 GMT by FMAdmin Someone
Market making, STP and ECN - what they are, pros and cons

One of the most intriguing issues in online Forex trading is what is a market maker, STP and ECN and what are the differences and similarities between them and what the benefits for traders are. First of all you can start by reading a more extensive overview of the aforementioned: Part1 and Part2.

Below is the short summary:

Market Maker (MM), also called a Dealing Desk (DD): MM is an artificial type of broker because it doesn't reflect the market directly, but simply quotes prices which are similar to what the market displays. Any order you enter is processed internally and never goes out to the market.

Pros: Quick execution (typically no re-quotes)

Cons: Every dollar you gain goes out of the broker's pocket and every dollar you lose ends up in its pocket = major conflict of interest.

Straight Through Processing (STP): This type of broker typically routes some or all of your orders directly to the market. This is a hybrid model between MM and ECN. Some brokers though say they are STP while they are actually MM, you can never tell and sometimes they do a bit of both - MM for losers and STP for winners.

Pros: Smaller conflict of interest, more accurate prices

Cons: Slow execution with plenty of re-quotes, if you are a loser your broker might end up moving you to market making servers

Electronic Communications Network (ECN) ): Is the only type of a broker per-se. Like in equities - brokers are supposed to let you gain access to the market not be the market (like in MM or STP sometimes). So a true ECN broker lets you see the actual prices and display the order in the market. You trade with other traders and financial institutions but not against your broker.

Pros: Direct market, no conflict of interest, typically no spread mark-up

Cons: No guaranteed fills, smallest lot possible is 100k (although I heard FXOpen are working on introducing a solution to smaller players) and there is a commission involved (albeit much lower than the spread you pay to MM and STP).

Any questions and clarifications are welcome at the dedicated forum thread.

One of the most intriguing issues in online Forex trading is what is a market maker, STP and ECN and what are the differences and similarities between them and what the benefits for traders are. First of all you can start by reading a more extensive overview of the aforementioned: Part1 and Part2.

Below is the short summary:

Market Maker (MM), also called a Dealing Desk (DD): MM is an artificial type of broker because it doesn't reflect the market directly, but simply quotes prices which are similar to what the market displays. Any order you enter is processed internally and never goes out to the market.

Pros: Quick execution (typically no re-quotes)

Cons: Every dollar you gain goes out of the broker's pocket and every dollar you lose ends up in its pocket = major conflict of interest.

Straight Through Processing (STP): This type of broker typically routes some or all of your orders directly to the market. This is a hybrid model between MM and ECN. Some brokers though say they are STP while they are actually MM, you can never tell and sometimes they do a bit of both - MM for losers and STP for winners.

Pros: Smaller conflict of interest, more accurate prices

Cons: Slow execution with plenty of re-quotes, if you are a loser your broker might end up moving you to market making servers

Electronic Communications Network (ECN) ): Is the only type of a broker per-se. Like in equities - brokers are supposed to let you gain access to the market not be the market (like in MM or STP sometimes). So a true ECN broker lets you see the actual prices and display the order in the market. You trade with other traders and financial institutions but not against your broker.

Pros: Direct market, no conflict of interest, typically no spread mark-up

Cons: No guaranteed fills, smallest lot possible is 100k (although I heard FXOpen are working on introducing a solution to smaller players) and there is a commission involved (albeit much lower than the spread you pay to MM and STP).

Any questions and clarifications are welcome at the dedicated forum thread.

Topics
forex
mt4
traders
brokers
fx
fxcm
fxdd
gbpusd
metatrader
About the Author: FMAdmin Someone
FMAdmin Someone
  • 1245 Articles
  • 16 Followers
sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf sdf

More from the Author

Retail FX

FMLS:24 panel on "Swimming Naked? Liquidity Amid Market Hiccups"

FMLS:24 panel on "Swimming Naked? Liquidity Amid Market Hiccups"

FMLS:24 panel on "Swimming Naked? Liquidity Amid Market Hiccups"

FMLS:24 panel on "Swimming Naked? Liquidity Amid Market Hiccups"
More Videos

  • FM's Editor-in-Chief Yam Yehoshua on how the newsroom evaluates stories.

    FM's Editor-in-Chief Yam Yehoshua on how the newsroom evaluates stories.

    FM's Editor-in-Chief Yam Yehoshua on how the newsroom evaluates stories.

    FM's Editor-in-Chief Yam Yehoshua on how the newsroom evaluates stories.

  • Matthew Smith, Group CEO at EC Markets, speaking at FMLS:24

    Matthew Smith, Group CEO at EC Markets, speaking at FMLS:24

    Matthew Smith, Group CEO at EC Markets, speaking at FMLS:24

    Matthew Smith, Group CEO at EC Markets, speaking at FMLS:24

  • Finance Magnates Annual Awards 2024 | FM Awards 2024 Highlights

    Finance Magnates Annual Awards 2024 | FM Awards 2024 Highlights

    🎥Catch the best moments from the Finance Magnates Annual Awards Gala Dinner! An evening where top names in finance came together to celebrate achievements, enjoy live music, and connect over a memorable dinner. Watch the highlights and feel the energy of our first gala in Cyprus! Congratulations to all the winners for their dedication to excellence and leadership in the financial industry, including XM, Trading PRO, FP Markets, Deriv, FxPro, LATAM, Headway, ATFX, FBS, AMEGA, EC Markets, Axi For more information about the 1st Finance Magnates Annual Awards, visit https://bit.ly/3Zb7wNz #FinanceMagnatesGala #IndustryExcellence #GalaHighlights #FinanceMagnatesAnnualAwards #FinanceMagnatesAwards #CelebratingSuccess #FinanceCommunity

    🎥Catch the best moments from the Finance Magnates Annual Awards Gala Dinner! An evening where top names in finance came together to celebrate achievements, enjoy live music, and connect over a memorable dinner. Watch the highlights and feel the energy of our first gala in Cyprus! Congratulations to all the winners for their dedication to excellence and leadership in the financial industry, including XM, Trading PRO, FP Markets, Deriv, FxPro, LATAM, Headway, ATFX, FBS, AMEGA, EC Markets, Axi For more information about the 1st Finance Magnates Annual Awards, visit https://bit.ly/3Zb7wNz #FinanceMagnatesGala #IndustryExcellence #GalaHighlights #FinanceMagnatesAnnualAwards #FinanceMagnatesAwards #CelebratingSuccess #FinanceCommunity

  • FMLS:24 | Shaping the Next Era of Financial Evolution

    FMLS:24 | Shaping the Next Era of Financial Evolution

    Welcome to FMLS:24 – the premier event where influential brands and leaders in trading, payments, fintech, and digital assets come together! Join over 2,500 industry professionals, engage with 150+ expert speakers, and discover endless opportunities with 70+ top exhibitors. FMLS:24 is where senior executives and decision-makers gather to close deals, forge new partnerships, and strengthen connections with long-term clients. Whether you’re in finance, technology, or payments, this summit is your gateway to future growth, meaningful collaborations, and industry-leading insights. 👉 Don't miss out – secure your ticket now at https://events.financemagnates.com/ZQEYy0?utm_source=youtube&utm_campaign=fmls24-awareness&utm_medium=video&RefId=MLS%3A24+Video+Promo #fmls #fmls24 #fmevents #financemagnates #forex #payments #crypto #events #london #fintech #ai #generativeai #technology #onlinetrading #forex #investing #investors #tech 📣 Stay updated with the latest in finance and trading! Follow FMevents across our social media platforms for news, insights, and event updates. Connect with us today: 🔗 LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/showcase/financemagnates-events/ 👍 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/FinanceMagnatesEvents 📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/fmevents_official 🐦 Twitter: https://twitter.com/F_M_events 🎥 TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@fmevents_official ▶️ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@FinanceMagnates_official Don't miss out on our latest videos, interviews, and event coverage. Subscribe to our YouTube channel for more!

    Welcome to FMLS:24 – the premier event where influential brands and leaders in trading, payments, fintech, and digital assets come together! Join over 2,500 industry professionals, engage with 150+ expert speakers, and discover endless opportunities with 70+ top exhibitors. FMLS:24 is where senior executives and decision-makers gather to close deals, forge new partnerships, and strengthen connections with long-term clients. Whether you’re in finance, technology, or payments, this summit is your gateway to future growth, meaningful collaborations, and industry-leading insights. 👉 Don't miss out – secure your ticket now at https://events.financemagnates.com/ZQEYy0?utm_source=youtube&utm_campaign=fmls24-awareness&utm_medium=video&RefId=MLS%3A24+Video+Promo #fmls #fmls24 #fmevents #financemagnates #forex #payments #crypto #events #london #fintech #ai #generativeai #technology #onlinetrading #forex #investing #investors #tech 📣 Stay updated with the latest in finance and trading! Follow FMevents across our social media platforms for news, insights, and event updates. Connect with us today: 🔗 LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/showcase/financemagnates-events/ 👍 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/FinanceMagnatesEvents 📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/fmevents_official 🐦 Twitter: https://twitter.com/F_M_events 🎥 TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@fmevents_official ▶️ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@FinanceMagnates_official Don't miss out on our latest videos, interviews, and event coverage. Subscribe to our YouTube channel for more!