We’ve just emerged from that time of year when an awful lot of the world has gorged themselves on chocolate bunnies and eggs. But might this Easter have been the last time chocolatey indulgence was on the menu? With cocoa surging harder than Bitcoin, just maybe.

In the future your favorite chocolate bunny will have slimmed down, and your strawberries will only be half-dipped. Welcome to Easter 2025, where the only thing thicker than the chocolate is the price tag. OK, let’s stop this futuristic fever dream and unwrap the mystery of the skyrocketing cocoa prices and why commodity traders are licking their lips.

Cocoa – The Numbers

But before we do, let’s just pause for a moment of contemplation - The price of cocoa has tripled over the last 12 months. The world is facing the largest deficit of cocoa supply in over 60 years. The International Cocoa Organization (yes, that’s a thing, no Willy Wonka does not head it up) forecasts huge shortages compared to last season. Hedge funds have gone in big, with over $8.7 billion in bets via cocoa futures products that prices will continue to rise.

Over the past year, cocoa prices have surged 204%, outpacing Bitcoin, which looks decidedly pedestrian with nearly 133% gains since last March.

Cocoa. Yes. The bean. The chocolate bean. On the same page? Great.

Better than Bitcoin: brown gold…#cocoa #chocolate #bitcoin pic.twitter.com/jNwx3qomMa

— Javier Blas (@JavierBlas) March 26, 2024

More Precious Than Precious Metals

Move over, gold and silver; cocoa beans are the trader’s new bling. Surging faster than a Bitcoin during a bull run, cocoa prices have hopped past their 1977 record of $5,400 per metric ton, reaching a sweet (or should I say bitter?) high of $10,000 per metric ton. Hence my earlier concern about next year’s Easter bunnies.

A Bitter Harvest: The Supply Side Story

The root of our cocoa woes lies in West Africa, the powerhouse of global production. Unfortunately, extreme weather and climate changes have played havoc with cocoa crops in Ivory Coast and Ghana, leading to the biggest cocoa deficit in decades. So if you thought your investment portfolio was volatile, spare a thought for the cocoa market, reeling under an almost 11% decline in global supply. Add to that inherent issues with the regional cocoa trade and fierce competition between international producers, and you’ve got problems.

A Sticky Situation: The Industry's Response

Chocolatiers aren't just sitting still. In response to this sticky situation, some companies have become creative. Mars is turning the shrink ray on its chocolate bars, and has been doing so for a while, but shoppers are still being put off by the price of a KitKat.

Paying More for Less

It's a tough time to be a chocoholic. Chocolate prices in major U.S. stores have leapt nearly 15% since the start of the year. In contrast, non-chocolate candy has only seen a modest 4% rise. And while some brands are offering more significant discounts to offset these higher prices, it seems the era of cheap chocolate indulgence is slowly melting away.

The Future of Chocolate: What's Next?

The cocoa market isn't showing signs of sweet relief anytime soon. With uncertainties looming over when the cocoa harvests will return to health, experts predict further price hikes and possibly more creative adaptations from chocolate companies. At the end of the day, chocolate is a luxury. So, it might be time to start exploring other avenues for personal pleasure.

The world of chocolate is facing a seismic shift, with prices rising faster than a soufflé in a hot oven. While this may mean our Easter treats are a little lighter (both in weight and on the wallet) next year, it's a fascinating example of how global market forces can impact something as simple and beloved as chocolate. So the next time you unwrap a chocolate bar, take a moment to savor it – it's a little piece of luxury in an increasingly expensive cocoa world. Just imagine, maybe one day a chocolate coin wrapped in gold foil might be more expensive than a Bitcoin...

For more finance-adjacent pieces like this, visit our Trending section.